Section 4: Operational d etail
| H1 | p167
Royal Commission on Genetic M odification | Report Appendix 1
Operational detail
4.
section 4.2 |
appendix 1
Context and process
Contents
4.
Operational detail
156
4.2

Schedule of Formal Hearings 168
Schedule of Formal Hearings and Persons appearing before
the Commission
168
Formal Hearings (weeks 1­12)
168
Additional Hearings
182
Rebuttal and New Evidence
183
Closing and Legal Submissions
183
p168 |
Section 4: Operational detail
Report Appendix 1 | Royal Commission on Genetic M odification
4.2 Schedule of Formal
Hearings
Schedule of Formal Hearings and Persons
appearing before the Commission
The following is a schedule of the Formal Hearings, additional Hearings, Rebuttal
and New Evidence, and Closing and Legal Submissions undertaken and presented
during the course of the inquiry.
Formal Hearings (weeks 1­12)
Date &
In order of appearance
Appearing for
Cross examined by
location before the Commission
(Interested Person
and on behalf of
of
(counsel, presenter,
name & no.)
hearing witnesses)
16 Oct 00 Chris Hodson QC
Aventis Crop
Derek Broadmore [IP61, 58,
Wgtn
Andrew Glynn
Science Pty
104, 53, 81]
Robert MacDonald
Ltd
Susie Lees [IP100]
Naomi Stevens
[IP14]
Jeanette Fitzsimons [IP83]
Sue Kedgley [IP83]
Alan Fricker [IP51]
Duncan Currie [IP82]
Grant Pearson [RCGM]
16 Oct 00 Chris Hodson QC
DuPont
Gareth Bodle [IP61, 58, 104,
Wgtn
Fergie Sumich
New Zealand
53, 81]
Clive Holland
Ltd [IP1]
Susie Lees [IP100]
Leo Hyde
Grant Pearson [RCGM]
17 Oct 00 Carrene Campbell
Carter Holt Harvey
Mr Rautner [IP82, 78]
Wgtn
James Griffiths
Ltd & Fletcher
Grant Pearson [RCGM]
Dr Geoff Webber
Challenge Forests
William Stirling Te Aho
Ltd [IP17] and New
Murray Parish
Zealand Forest
Helen Atkins
Industries Council
[IP9]
Joint presentation
Section 4: Operational d etail
| H1 | p169
Royal Commission on Genetic M odification | Report Appendix 1
17 Oct 00 Michael Holm
AgResearch [IP13]
Gareth Bodle [IP61, 58, 104,
Wgtn
Dr Keith Steel
53, 81]
Dr Patricia Harris
Sue Kedgley [IP100]
Dr Kenneth McNatty
Jeanette Fitzsimons [IP83]
Dr Phil L'Huillier
Alan Fricker [IP51]
Dr Derek Woodfield
Grant Pearson [RCGM]
Dr Stephen Goldson
18 Oct 00 James Guthrie
Crop & Food
Duncan Currie [IP63]
Wgtn
Dr Michael Dunbier
Research Ltd [IP4]
Seager Mason [IP61, 58, 104,
Dr Anthony Connor
53, 81]
Dr Gail Timmerman-Vaughan
Sue Kedgley [IP63]
Dr Kevin Davies
Grant Pearson [RCGM]
18 Oct 00 James Guthrie
Forest Research
Duncan Currie [IP82]
Wgtn
Dr Chris Walter
Institute [IP2]
Dr Michael Carson
18 Oct 00 Dr Ian Warrington
The Horticulture and
Seager Mason [IP61, 58, 104,
Wgtn
Dr Richard Newcomb
Food Research
53, 81]
Dr Susan Gardiner
Institute of New
Jeanette Fitzsimons [IP83]
Dr Daniel Cohen
Zealand Ltd
heard on 19 Oct 00
Dr Louise Malone
(HortResearch)
Grant Pearson [RCGM]
Dr Susan Muggleston
[IP5]
heard on 19 Oct 00
Dr Gavin Ross
19 Oct 00 James Guthrie
Landcare Research
Dr Sean Weaver [IP83, 100]
Wgtn
Dr Andrew Pearce
[IP12]
Alan Fricker [IP51]
Dr Dianne Gleeson
Dr Peter Maddison [IP79]
Dr Phil Cowan
Grant Pearson [RCGM]
Roger Wilkinson
19 Oct 00 Forrie Miller
Wrightson Ltd [IP3]
Jeanette Fitzsimons [IP83]
Wgtn
Dr Allan Freeth
Warwick Green
24 Oct 00 Mark Christensen
Institute of Molecular Jim Kebbell [IP61, 58, 104,
Wgtn
Prof Patrick Sullivan
BioSciences
53, 81]
Dr Michael McManus
(Massey University)
Grant Pearson [RCGM]
Dr Stephen Sarre
[IP15]
Date &
In order of appearance
Appearing for
Cross examined by
location
before the Commission
(Interested Person
and on behalf of
of hearing (counsel, presenter,
name & no.)
witnesses)
p170 |
Section 4: Operational detail
Report Appendix 1 | Royal Commission on Genetic M odification
Dr Rosie Bradshaw
Prof Barry Scott
24 Oct 00 Mark Christensen
Malaghan Institute of Jim Kebbell [IP61, 58, 104,
Wgtn
Dr Berridge
Medical Research
53, 81]
Dr Nicola Harris
[IP10]
Grant Pearson [RCGM]
25 Oct 00 Chris Hodson QC
University of
Jeanette Fitzsimons [IP83]
Wgtn
Prof Marston Conder
Auckland [IP16]
Grant Pearson [RCGM]
Assoc Prof Ingrid Winship
Prof Garth Cooper
Prof Richard Bellamy
25 Oct 00 Chris Hodson QC
University of Otago
Dr Sean Weaver [IP83]
Wgtn
Dr Ian Smith
[IP19]
Grant Pearson [RCGM]
Dr Glenn Buchan
Dr Parry Guilford
Dr Graham Wallis
Dr Iain Lamont
Assoc Prof Clive Ronson
25 Oct 00 Chris Hodson QC
Monsanto New
Derek Broadmore [IP61, 58, 104,
Wgtn
Brian Arnst
Zealand [IP6]
53, 81]
Murray Willocks
Duncan Currie [IP82, 102]
Sue Kedgley [IP83]
Susie Lees [IP100]
Alan Fricker [IP51]
Grant Pearson [RCGM]
26 Oct 00 Prof Roy Bickerstaffe
Lincoln University
Susie Lees & Claire Bleakley
Wgtn
Matthew Kent
[IP8]
[IP100]
Dr Jonathan Hickford
Dr Barry Palmer
Prof Alison Stewart
Dr Robin McFarlane
Prof Roger Field
27 Oct 00 Dr Andrew Pratt
University of
Grant Pearson [RCGM]
Wgtn
Dr Jack Heinemann
Canterbury [IP7]
Date &
In order of appearance
Appearing for
Cross examined by
location
before the Commission
(Interested Person
and on behalf of
of hearing (counsel, presenter,
name & no.)
witnesses)
Schedule of Formal Hearings (continued)
Section 4: Operational d etail
| H1 | p171
Royal Commission on Genetic M odification | Report Appendix 1
27 Oct 00 Jennifer Murphy
Genesis Research & Alan Fricker [IP51]
Wgtn
Dr Arie Guersen
Development Corp
Grant Pearson [RCGM]
Dr Andrew Shenk
Ltd [IP11]
30 Oct 00 David Parker
A2 Corporation Ltd
Grant Pearson [RCGM]
Wgtn
[IP26]
30 Oct 00 Mark Christensen
Auckland
Grant Pearson [RCGM]
Wgtn
Dr John Kernohan
UniServices Ltd
Prof Peter Gluckman
[IP23]
Prof John Mattick
31 Oct 00 Mark Christensen
Association of
Duncan Currie [IP82, 102]
Wgtn
Dr Sean Devine
Crown Research
Derek Broadmore [IP61, 58, 104,
Dr Adolf Stoombergen
Institutes [IP22]
53, 81]
Grant Pearson [RCGM]
31 Oct 00 Mark Christensen
BIOTENZ [IP25]
Derek Broadmore [IP61, 58, 104,
Wgtn
Dr William Rolleston
53, 81]
Basil Wakelin
Duncan Currie [IP102]
Grant Pearson [RCGM]
01 Nov 00 Chris Hodson QC
New Zealand Life
Alan Fricker [IP51]
Wgtn
Dr William Rolleston
Sciences Network
Duncan Currie [IP82, 103]
Paora Ammunson
(Incorporated) [IP24]
Jeanette Fitzsimons [IP83]
Tamati Cairns
and New Zealand
Ripeke Ellison [IP64]
Prof Klaus Amman
Vice Chancellors
Grant Pearson [RCGM]
Committee [IP18]
Joint presentation
02 Nov 00 Dr Bruce Scroggins
Health Research
Mark Christensen [IP24]
Wgtn
Council of New
Grant Pearson [RCGM]
Zealand [IP27]
02 Nov 00 Gowan Pickering
Foundation for
Mark Christensen [IP24]
Wgtn
Nick Allison
Research, Science
Grant Pearson [RCGM]
Dr Marie Bradley
and Technology
Liz Prendergast
[IP21]
13 Nov 00 Derek Keene
Northland
Mark Christensen [IP24]
Akld
Hally Toia
Conservation Board
Grant Pearson [RCGM]
[IP68]
Date &
In order of appearance
Appearing for
Cross examined by
location
before the Commission
(Interested Person
and on behalf of
of hearing (counsel, presenter,
name & no.)
witnesses)
p172 |
Section 4: Operational detail
Report Appendix 1 | Royal Commission on Genetic M odification
13 Nov 00 Mr Pomare
Koanga Gardens
Grant Pearson [RCGM]
Akld
Michael O'Donnell
Trust Incorporated
Kay Baxter
[IP72]
Bob Corker
13 Nov 00 Tom Bennion
Witness appearing
Denys Trussle [IP78]
Akld
Assoc Prof Peter Wills
for IP107, 82, 83,
John Carapiet [IP63]
78, 51, 84, 89
Mark Christensen [IP24]
Grant Pearson [RCGM]
20 Nov 00 Alan McKenzie
New Zealand
Derek Broadmore [IP61, 58, 104,
Wgtn
Warren Larsen
Dairy Board [IP67]
53, 81]
Dr Joan Wright
Tom Bennion [IP 83, 51]
Dr Kevin Marshall
Brendan Brown QC [RCGM]
Dr John Yeabsley
Juliet Maclean
Ms Bromley
20 Nov 00 Alan McKenzie
New Zealand
Tom Bennion [IP83]
Wgtn
Ms Bromley
Cooperative Dairy
Brendan Brown QC [RCGM]
Peter Hobman
Company [IP88]
Dr Robert Welch
21 Nov 00 Chris Hodson QC
Meat Industry
Duncan Currie [IP82]
Wgtn
Neil Taylor
Assocation of New
Gareth Bodle [IP61, 58, 104,
John Miller
Zealand [IP32] and
53, 81]
Ross Townsend
Meat New Zealand
Tom Bennion [IP 83, 51]
Collier Isaacs
[IP31] and New
Brendan Brown QC [RCGM]
Rob Davison
Zealand Game
Brian Lynch
Industry Board [IP33]
Dr Alex Sundakov
joint presentation
Julian Morris
Prof Martina McGloughlin
Robin Campbell
22 Nov 00 Chris Hodson QC
Agcarm
Tom Bennion [IP83, 51]
Wgtn
Dr Jack Richardson
Incorporated [IP29]
Duncan Currie [IP82]
Prof Gary Comstock
Brendan Brown QC [RCGM]
Date &
In order of appearance
Appearing for
Cross examined by
location
before the Commission
(Interested Person
and on behalf of
of hearing (counsel, presenter,
name & no.)
witnesses)
Schedule of Formal Hearings (continued)
Section 4: Operational d etail
| H1 | p173
Royal Commission on Genetic M odification | Report Appendix 1
Date &
In order of appearance
Appearing for
Cross examined by
location
before the Commission
(Interested Person
and on behalf of
of hearing (counsel, presenter,
name & no.)
witnesses)
22 Nov 00 Chris Hodson QC
Federated Farmers
Gareth Bodle [IP61, 58, 104,
Wgtn
Alistair Polson
of New Zealand
53, 81]
Thomas Lambie
[IP34]
Duncan Currie [IP82]
John Aspinall
Tom Bennion [IP83]
Neil Barton
Brendan Brown QC [RCGM]
Peter Corish
Malcolm Bailey
23 Nov 00 Chris Hodson QC
New Zealand
Gareth Bodle [IP61 , 58, 104,
Wgtn
Prof Bill Manktelow
Veterinary
53, 81]
Assoc Prof Richard Squires Association
Sue Kedgley [IP83]
Jim Guthrie
Incorporated [IP28]
Tom Bennion [IP63]
Dr Lynn Frewer
Brendan Brown QC [RCGM]
23 Nov 00 Chris Hodson QC
New Zealand Wool
Tom Bennion [IP63]
Wgtn
Mark O'Grady
Board [IP30]
Brendan Brown QC [RCGM]
Dr Maurice Ormsby
Hon. David Caygill
Dr Alex Sundakov
Dr Peter Fennessy
27 Nov 00 Chris Hodson QC
New Zealand
Tom Bennion [IP83, 61, 58,
Wgtn
Brenda Cutress
Grocery Marketers
104, 53, 81]
Dr Lawrence Eyres
Association [IP54]
Brendan Brown QC [RCGM]
Dr Geoffrey Annison
Michael Rosser
Dick Hubbard
27 Nov 00 Chris Hodson QC
New Zealand
Tom Bennion [IP 51, 61, 58,
Wgtn
Dr Hilton Furness
Arable-Food
104, 53, 81, 83]
Warwick Green
Industry Council
Brendan Brown QC [RCGM]
Dr Brian Jordan
[IP56]
Graham Robertson
28 Nov 00 Colin Harvey
New Zealand
Tom Bennion [IP83]
Wgtn
Agritech [IP73]
Brendan Brown QC [RCGM]
p174 |
Section 4: Operational detail
Report Appendix 1 | Royal Commission on Genetic M odification
28 Nov 00 Chris Hodson QC
New Zealand Feed
Duncan Currie [IP82]
Wgtn
Mr Foulds
Manufacturers
Tom Bennion [IP63, 83]
Dr Phillip Salisbury
Association (Inc);
Brendan Brown QC [RCGM]
Poultry Industry
Association of New
Zealand (Inc);
Egg Producers
Federation of New
Zealand [IP35]
29 Nov 00 Chris Hodson QC
New Zealand
Gareth Bodle [IP61, 58, 104,
Wgtn
Peter Silcock
Vegetable and
53, 81]
Dr Neil Stewart
Potato Growers'
Dr Audrey Jarvis [IP49]
Dr Steven Hughes
Federation (Inc);
Richard Davis [IP49]
Peter Ensor
New Zealand
Duncan Currie [IP82]
Fruitgrowers'
Tom Bennion [IP83]
Federation (Inc);
Grant Pearson [RCGM]
New Zealand
Berryfruit
Growers Federation
(Inc) [IP75]
30 Nov 00 did not appear
New Zealand Worm
Wgtn
Federation [IP94]
30 Nov 00 Dr Nigel Banks
ZESPRI
Jeanette Fitzsimons [IP83]
Wgtn
Tony Marks
International Ltd
Tom Bennion [IP63]
Jane Lancaster
[IP46]
Chris Hodson QC [IP24]
Grant Pearson [RCGM]
04 Dec 00 Derek Broadmore
Bio Dynamic
Sue Kedgley [IP83]
Wgtn
David Wright
Farming and
Chris Hodson QC [IP24]
Dr Ann Clark
Gardening
Grant Pearson [RCGM]
Jim Kebbell
Association in New
Gareth Bodle
Zealand [IP61] and
Noel Josephson
Commonsense
Dr Johannes Wirz
Organics [IP66]
joint presentation
Date &
In order of appearance
Appearing for
Cross examined by
location
before the Commission
(Interested Person
and on behalf of
of hearing (counsel, presenter,
name & no.)
witnesses)
Schedule of Formal Hearings (continued)
Section 4: Operational d etail
| H1 | p175
Royal Commission on Genetic M odification | Report Appendix 1
05 Dec 00 Derek Broadmore
BIO-GRO New
Chris Hodson QC [IP24]
Wgtn
Seager Mason
Zealand [IP58] and
Susie Lees [IP100]
Gary Goldberg
Golden Bay Organic
Grant Pearson [RCGM]
Percy Schmeiser
Employment and
Jeanette Fitzsimons [IP83]
Laverne Aflleck
(by video link)
Education Trust
Grant Pearson [RCGM]
Jeff Hay
[IP104]
Gareth Bodle
joint presentation
06 Dec 00 Gareth Bodle
Organic Product
Ian Ewen-Street [IP83]
Wgtn
John Manhire
Exporters Group
Chris Hodson QC [IP24]
Dr Hugh Campbell
[IP53] and Organic
Grant Pearson [RCGM]
Dr John Fairweather
Federation New
Prof Caroline Saunders
Zealand [IP81]
Brendan Hoare
joint presentation
Russell Simmons
Marty Robinson
Zelka Grammer
Dr Andy Cook
07 Dec 00 Bill Bracks
Comvita
Jon Muller [IP63]
Wgtn
New Zealand
Chris Hodson QC [RCGM]
[IP74]
Grant Pearson [RCGM]
11 Dec 00 Assoc Prof Ingrid Winship Auckland
Brendan Brown QC [RCGM]
Wgtn
Healthcare Services
Limited [IP91]
11 Dec 00 Terrance Aschoff
Researched
Francis Wevers [IP24]
Wgtn
Dr Gillian Woollett
Medicines Industry
John Stroh [IP83]
Linda McLaughlan
Association of New
Brendan Brown QC [RCGM]
Zealand [IP55]
12 Dec 00 Crystal Bridger
Diabetes Youth New
Dr Sean Weaver [IP83]
Wgtn
Prof Bob Elliot
Zealand [IP60]
Brendan Brown QC [RCGM]
Assoc Prof Daniel Thiebaud
Dr Ronald Chance
Lebuinus Vink
Date &
In order of appearance
Appearing for
Cross examined by
location
before the Commission
(Interested Person
and on behalf of
of hearing (counsel, presenter,
name & no.)
witnesses)
p176 |
Section 4: Operational detail
Report Appendix 1 | Royal Commission on Genetic M odification
12 Dec 00 Roger Daube
Cystic Fibrosis
Francis Wevers [IP24]
Wgtn
Margaret Nicholls
Association of New
Jeanette Fitzsimons [IP83]
Zealand [IP39]
Brendan Brown QC [RCGM]
13 Dec 00 Dr Dianne Webster
National Testing
Wgtn
Centre [IP44]
13 Dec 00 John Forman
Lysosomal Diseases
Francis Wevers [IP24]
Wgtn
Paul and Jenny Noble
New Zealand [IP99]
Dr Sean Weaver [IP83]
Sharon Kortas
Brendan Brown QC [RCGM]
Assoc Prof Mike Eccles
Anita Nicholls
Bronwyn Gray
Dr Michael Sullivan
Dr Dianne Webster
14 Dec 00 Alan Fricker
Sustainable Futures
Chris Hodson QC [IP24]
Wgtn
Prof Brian Goodwin (by
Trust [IP51]
Brendan Brown QC [RCGM]
telephone)
14 Dec 00 Michael Carnahan
Haemophilia
Brendan Brown QC [RCGM]
Wgtn
Dion York
Foundation New
Zealand [IP48]
23 Jan 01 Dr Selwyn Yorke
New Zealand
Luke Anderson [IP63]
Wgtn
Dr Max Kennedy
Biotechnology
Jeanette Fitzsimons [IP83]
Association [IP47]
John Upton QC [RCGM]
23 Jan 01 Dr John Clearwater
Physicians and
Mark Christensen [IP24]
Wgtn
Dr Bernard Conlon
Scientists for
John Upton QC [RCGM]
Dr Michael Godfrey
Responsible
Christy Hartlage
Genetics New
Dr Neil Macgregor
Zealand [IP107]
24 Jan 01 Dr Mike Berridge
New Zealand
Steven Druker [IP63,100]
Wgtn
Prof David Penny
Association of
Luke Anderson [IP83]
Dr Fiona McDonald
Scientists [IP92]
John Upton QC [RCGM]
Dr David Heath
Date &
In order of appearance
Appearing for
Cross examined by
location
before the Commission
(Interested Person
and on behalf of
of hearing (counsel, presenter,
name & no.)
witnesses)
Schedule of Formal Hearings (continued)
Section 4: Operational d etail
| H1 | p177
Royal Commission on Genetic M odification | Report Appendix 1
24 Jan 01 Dr Steve Thompson
Royal Society of
Steven Druker [IP63,100]
Wgtn
Rosemary Du Plessis
New Zealand
Mark Christensen [IP24]
Prof George Peterson
[IP77]
Luke Anderson [IP83]
John Upton QC [RCGM]
25 Jan 01 Dr Max Suckling
New Zealand Plant
Dr Robin Ord [IP87]
Wgtn
Protection Society
John Upton QC [RCGM]
[IP36]
25 Jan 01 Dr Don Love
Human Genetics
Jeanette Fitzsimons [IP83]
Wgtn
Dr Joanne Dixon
Society of
Dr Robin Ord [IP87]
Dr Andrew Shelling
Australasia New
John Upton QC [RCGM]
Dr Ingrid Winship
Zealand Branch
[IP59]
25 Jan 01 Dr Martin Kennedy
New Zealand
Sue Kedgley [IP83]
Wgtn
Dr Ian McLennan
(by video
Transgenic Animal
Dr Robin Ord [IP87]
link)
Users [IP45]
John Upton QC [RCGM]
Dr Kyoko Koishi
(by video
link)
26 Jan 01 Ross Wilson
New Zealand
Don Murray [IP100]
Wgtn
Peter Conway
Council of Trade
John Upton QC [RCGM]
Unions [IP95]
26 Jan 01 Doug Calhoun
Institute of Patent
Duncan Currie [IP82]
Wgtn
Megan Williams
Attorneys [IP71]
Dr Robin Ord [IP87]
Jared Scartlett
Don Murray [IP100]
Jane Calvert
John Upton QC [RCGM]
29 Jan 01 Alison White
Pesticide Action
Don Murray [IP100]
Wgtn
Dr Judy Carman
Network New
Chris Hodson [IP24]
Dr Robin Ord
Zealand [IP87]
29 Jan 01 Tee Rogers-Hayden
Safe Food
Don Murray [IP100]
Wgtn
Sue Kedgley
Campaign [IP86]
Chris Hodson QC [IP24]
John Upton QC [RCGM]
30 Jan 01 John Muller
GE Free New
Chris Hodson QC [IP24]
Wgtn
Guy Hatchard
Zealand (RAGE) in
John Upton QC [RCGM]
Mae-Wan Ho
(by video link)
Food and
Date &
In order of appearance
Appearing for
Cross examined by
location
before the Commission
(Interested Person
and on behalf of
of hearing (counsel, presenter,
name & no.)
witnesses)
p178 |
Section 4: Operational detail
Report Appendix 1 | Royal Commission on Genetic M odification
Date &
In order of appearance
Appearing for
Cross examined by
location
before the Commission
(Interested Person
and on behalf of
of hearing (counsel, presenter,
name & no.)
witnesses)
Jon Carapiet
Environment [IP63]
Joe Cummins
(by video link)
30 Jan 01 Don Murray
Nelson GE Free
Chris Hodson QC [IP24]
Wgtn
Alan Saipe
Awareness Group
John Upton QC [RCGM]
Sol Morgan
[IP100]
Joe Rifici
Steven Druker
Susie Lees
31 Jan 01 Ron Law
National Nutritional
Chris Hodson QC [IP24]
Wgtn
Foods Association
Grant Pearson [RCGM]
of New Zealand
[IP106]
01 Feb 01 Jeanette Fitzsimons
Green Party of
Dr Guy Hatchard [IP63]
Wgtn
Dr Michael Antoniou
(by video link)
Aotearoa/New
Chris Hodson QC [IP24]
Dr Ann Clark
(by video link)
Zealand [IP83]
John Upton QC [RCGM]
Prof Phil Regal
(by video link)
Dr Elaine Ingham
(by video link)
Dr Scott Eastham
Sue Kedgley
01 Feb 01 Barry Foster
National
Chris Hodson QC [IP24]
Wgtn
Jane Lorimer
Beekeepers
John Upton [RCGM]
Bill Floyd
Association of New
Zealand, Poverty
Bay Branch [IP62]
07 Feb 01 Dr Cliff Mason
Pacific Institute of
John Carapiet [IP63]
Wtgn
Dr Neil MacGregor
Resource
Chris Hodson QC [IP24]
Dr Joan Mattingley-Cameron Management [IP84]
Grant Pearson [RCGM]
Dr Beatrix Tappeser
Kay Weir
07 Feb 01 Denys Trussell
Friends of the Earth
John Carapiet [IP63]
Wgtn
Simon Reeves
[IP78]
Chris Hodson QC [IP24]
Dr Susan Bardocz
Grant Pearson [RCGM]
Schedule of Formal Hearings (continued)
Section 4: Operational d etail
| H1 | p179
Royal Commission on Genetic M odification | Report Appendix 1
Date &
In order of appearance
Appearing for
Cross examined by
location
before the Commission
(Interested Person
and on behalf of
of hearing (counsel, presenter,
name & no.)
witnesses)
Dr Arpad Pusztai
Dr Stanley Ewen
08 Feb 01 Keith Chapple
Royal Forest and
Chris Hodson QC [IP24]
Wtgn
Jocelyn Bieleski
Bird Protection
Brendan Brown QC [RCGM]
Dr Peter Maddison
Society of New
Mr Weeber
Zealand (including
Marlborough,
Nelson/Tasman
branches) [IP79,
40, 43]
joint presentation
09 Feb 01 Stephen Blyth
Environment and
Chris Hodson QC [IP24]
Wgtn
Craig Holdrege
(by video link)
Conservation
John Upton QC [RCGM]
Berylla
Organisations of
Luke Anderson
New Zealand [IP102]
15 Feb 01 Dr Guy Hatchard
Soil and Health
Chris Hodson QC [RCGM]
Akld
Brendan Hoare
Association of New
John Upton QC [RCGM
Meriel Watts
Zealand [IP97]
Dr Klaus Bosselmann
Dr John Clearwater
15 Feb 01 Gary Reese
SAFE (Save
John Forman [IP99, 98]
and
Joyce D'Silva
Animals From
Chris Hodson QC [IP24]
16 Feb 01 Prof Alan Holland
(by
Exploitation)
John Upton [RCGM]
Akld
video link)
[IP85]
Dr Michael Morris
16 Feb 01 Annette Cotter
Greenpeace New
John Forman [IP99]
Akld
Dr Doreen Stabinsky
Zealand [IP82]
Chris Hodson QC [IP24]
Dr Bill Christison
John Upton QC [RCGM]
Prof Terje Traavik
Anuradha Mittal
(by video link)
Prof Jonathan King
Denys Trussell
Stephanie Howard
Jim Thomas
p180 |
Section 4: Operational detail
Report Appendix 1 | Royal Commission on Genetic M odification
19 Feb 01 Dame Margaret Austin
New Zealand
Chris Hodson QC [IP24]
Wgtn
Prof Sylby Rumball
National
John Upton QC [RCGM]
Nadja Tollemache
Commission for
Susan Isaacs
UNESCO [IP90]
19 Feb 01 Margaret Millard
Rural Women New
Chris Hodson QC [IP24]
Wgtn
Liz Mende
Zealand [IP52]
John Upton QC [RCGM]
20 Feb 01 Prof Darryl Macer
(by
Eubios Ethics
Chris Hodson QC [IP24]
Wgtn
video link)
Institute [IP96]
John Upton QC [RCGM]
20 Feb 01 Rev Jim Greenaway
Anglican Church in
Chris Hodson QC [IP24]
Wgtn
Stephanie McIntyre
Aotearoa New
John Upton QC [RCGM]
Zealand and
Polynesia [IP42]
20 Feb 01 Hugh Scott
Public Questions
Chris Hodson QC [IP24]
Wgtn
Richard Davis
Committee
John Upton QC [RCGM]
(Methodist,
Presbyterian,
Churches of Christ,
Quaker) [IP93]
21 Feb 01 David Zwartz
New Zealand
John Upton QC [RCGM]
Wgtn
Hilary Phillips
Jewish Community
[IP80]
21 Feb 01 Dr Audrey Jarvis
Interchurch
Chris Hodson QC [IP99]
Wgtn
Dr Grant Gillett
Commission on
John Upton QC [RCGM]
Maree Pene
Genetic Engineering
Dr Vivienne Burrows
[IP49]
22 Feb 01 Jocelyn Thornton
Quaker Spiritual
John Forman [IP24]
Wgtn
Barbara Mountier
Ecology Group,
John Upton QC [RCGM]
Hilda Daw
Religious Society of
Anne Meuli
Friends [IP50]
Joanna Paul
Peter Harrison
22 Feb 01 Bishop Peter Cullinane
New Zealand
John Forman [IP99]
Wgtn
Anne Dickinson
Catholic Bishops'
John Upton QC [RCGM]
Dr Michael McCabe
Conference [IP38]
Date &
In order of appearance
Appearing for
Cross examined by
location
before the Commission
(Interested Person
and on behalf of
of hearing (counsel, presenter,
name & no.)
witnesses)
Schedule of Formal Hearings (continued)
Section 4: Operational d etail
| H1 | p181
Royal Commission on Genetic M odification | Report Appendix 1
23 Feb 01 Rex Verity
Canterbury
Mark Christianson [IP24]
Chch
Simon Musgrave
Commercial
Duncan Currie [IP82]
Tremane Barr
Organics Group
John Upton QC [RCGM]
Tim Chamberlain
[IP65]
John Guthrie
23 Feb 01 Mark Christianson
Witness appearing
Duncan Currie [IP82, 63]
Chch
Dr Patrick Moore
for IP24 and 35,
John Upton QC [RCGM]
23 Feb 01 Edward Ellison
Te Runanga o Ngai
Tom Christianson [IP24]
Chch
Tim Rochford
Tahu [IP41]
John Upton QC [RCGM]
Craig Paulin
Linda Constable
26 Feb 01 Maanu Paul
New Zealand Maori
Chris Webster [IP103]
Wgtn
Tu Williams
Council [IP105]
Chris Hodson QC [IP24]
John Upton QC [RCGM]
26 Feb 01 Annette Sykes
Nga Wahine Tiaki o
Paora Ammunson [IP24]
Wgtn
Leonie Pihama
te Ao [IP64]
Chris Webster [IP103]
Hariata Pohatu
John Upton QC [RCGM]
Angeline Greensill
Cheryl Smith
Jessica Hutchins
Tere Harrison
Ripeka Ellison-Orzecki
Dr Fiona Cram
27 Feb 01 Vivienne Taueki
Muaupoko
Chris Webster [IP103]
Wgtn
Co-operative
Grant Pearson [RCGM]
Society [IP57]
27 Feb 01 Tu Williams
Maori Congress
Paora Ammunson [IP24]
Wgtn
Chris Webster
[IP103]
Chris Hodson [IP24]
Grant Pearson [RCGM]
27 Feb 01 Paul Morgan
Federation of Maori
Paora Ammunson [IP24]
Wgtn
Jacob Haronga
Authorities [IP69]
Chris Webster [IP103]
Grant Pearson [RCGM]
Date &
In order of appearance
Appearing for
Cross examined by
location
before the Commission
(Interested Person
and on behalf of
of hearing (counsel, presenter,
name & no.)
witnesses)
p182 |
Section 4: Operational detail
Report Appendix 1 | Royal Commission on Genetic M odification
28 Feb 01 did not appear
WAI 262 Claimants,
Wgtn
Ngati Wai, Ngati Kuri,
Te Rarawa [IP89]
did not appear
28 Feb 01 Dr Morgan Williams
Parliamentary
Chris Hodson QC [IP24]
Wgtn
Dr Mark Lonsdale
Commissioner for
Chris Webster [IP103]
the Environment
John Upton QC [RCGM]
[IP70]
01 Mar 01 Marilyn Bramley
Ministry for the
Chris Hodson QC [IP24]
Wgtn
Dr Lin Roberts
Environment [IP101]
Pat Clark [IP63, 83]
Dr Steven Vaughan
Susie Lees [IP100]
Tony Robinson
Chris Webster [IP103]
Dr Abdul Moeed
John Upton QC [RCGM]
01 Mar 01 Dr Bas Walker
Environmental Risk
Chris Hodson QC [IP24]
and
Dr Oliver Sutherland
Management
Susie Lees [IP100]
02 Mar 01 Dr Mere Roberts
Authority [IP76]
Chris Webster [IP103]
Wgtn
Dr Donald Hannah
Joanna Paul [IP50]
Mr K Currie
Jessica Hutchings [IP64]
Gareth Bodle [IP 61, 58, 104,
53, 81]
Jeanette Fitzsimons [IP82]
Pat Clark [IP 63, 102]
Kay Weir [IP 84]
Duncan Currie [IP82]
Additional Hearings
08 Mar 01 Ian Lindenmayer
Australia and New
Chris Hodson QC [IP24]
Wgtn
Dr Marion Healy
Zealand Food
Sue Kedgley [IP 83, 86]
Dr Paul Brent
Authority
Susie Lees [IP 100, 102]
[general public
Mr Collins QC [IP63]
submission]
Mr Law [IP106]
Mr Mattingley-Cameron [IP84]
John Upton QC [RCGM]
Date &
In order of appearance
Appearing for
Cross examined by
location
before the Commission
(Interested Person
and on behalf of
of hearing (counsel, presenter,
name & no.)
witnesses)
Schedule of Formal Hearings (continued)
Section 4: Operational d etail
| H1 | p183
Royal Commission on Genetic M odification | Report Appendix 1
Rebuttal and New Evidence
12 Mar 01 John Forman
Lysosomal Diseases
Dr Sean Weaver [IP83]
Wgtn
Dr Dave Palmer
New Zealand [IP99]
Dr Mike Eccles
Closing and Legal Submissions
12 Mar 01 John Upton QC
Counsel Assisting the
Wgtn
Grant Pearson
Commission
12 Mar 01 Chris Hodson QC
New Zealand Life
Wgtn
Sciences Network
[IP24]
13 Mar 01 Alan McKenzie
New Zealand Dairy
Wgtn
Dr Joan Wright
Board [IP 67]
13 Mar 01 Dr Ian Warrington
Association of
Wgtn
Crown Research
Institutes [IP22],
Ag Research [IP13],
Crop and Food
Research [IP4],
HortResearch [IP5] and
Forest Research [IP2]
joint presentation
13 Mar 01 Dr Bas Walker
Environmental Risk
Wgtn
Management
Authority [IP 76]
13 Mar 01 Duncan Currie
Greenpeace New
Wgtn
Stephanie Howard
Zealand [IP82]
Tamsin Vuetilovoni
Royden Hindle
13 Mar 01 Alison White
Pesticide Action
Wgtn
Dr Robin Ord
Network New Zealand
[IP87]
Date &
In order of appearance
Appearing for
Cross examined by
location
before the Commission
(Interested Person
and on behalf of
of hearing (counsel, presenter,
name & no.)
witnesses)
p184 |
Section 4: Operational detail
Report Appendix 1 | Royal Commission on Genetic M odification
14 Mar 01 Susie Lees
Nelson GE Free
Wgtn
Awareness Group
[IP100]
14 Mar 01 Dr Morgan Williams
Parliamentary
Wgtn
Commissioner for the
Environment [IP70]
14 Mar 01 Pat Clark
GE Free New Zealand
Wgtn
John Carapiet
(RAGE) in Food and
Environment [IP63]
14 Mar 01 Simon Reeves
Friends of the Earth
Wgtn
(New Zealand) [IP78]
14 Mar 01 David Parker
A2 Corporation [IP26]
Wgtn
15 Mar 01 Tom Bennion
Green Party of
Wgtn
Jeanette Fitzimons
Aotearoa/New
Zealand [IP83]
15 Mar 01 Kay Weir
Pacific Institute of
Wgtn
Resource
Management [IP84],
15 Mar 01 John Forman
Lysosomal Diseases
Wgtn
New Zealand [IP99]
and New Zealand
Organisation for Rare
Diseases [IP98]
joint presentation
15 Mar 01 Dr Audrey Jarvis
Interchurch
Wgtn
Commission on
Genetic Modification
[IP 49]
Date &
In order of appearance
Appearing for
Cross examined by
location
before the Commission
(Interested Person
and on behalf of
of hearing (counsel, presenter,
name & no.)
witnesses)